517.8% lift How Facebook’s purchase event impacts instant donor conversion

Date Added: March 29, 2019 Research Partner: Care Net Element tested: Advertising

Care Net offers people the opportunity to get a free devotional called, Prayers for Life. This offer is promoted through paid Facebook ads. In previous testing with Care Net's online courses, we had found that the purchase event in Facebook significantly increased instant donor conversion. Because the Prayers for Life offer was a different kind of offer than the online courses where we saw that success we wanted to test this approach with this kind of offer as well to see if we'd get similar results. This campaign was originally set up using Facebook's custom conversion which was based on an event we manually set up. We tested this approach against Facebook's native purchase event. 



View the experiment »


39.3% lift How optimizing for a “Donate” event in Facebook affects instant donor conversion

Date Added: March 29, 2019 Research Partner: The Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate Element tested: Advertising

The Missionary Oblates previously validated an experiment that increased donor conversion for their content offer by optimizing for the native Facebook event "Purchase" rather than a custom conversion, or course signup. In test #10687, optimizing for purchase targeting led to a 284% increase in donors from the Lenten Prayers offer. This confirmed our hypothesis that Facebook shows ads to more donor-motivated people when optimizing for purchases. It allows them to pull in additional purchase data from Facebook instead of relying primarily on data that we give to them (for example, a list of prospects or a lookalike audience). In this test, we utilized the native event on Facebook labeled "Donate", to test if the same approach would increase donations even further knowing that Facebook was likely pulling in nonprofit or donor data as well as purchase data. All other campaign elements remained the same.

View the experiment »


-16.4% drop How carousel ad format promoting a survey decreased clickthrough rates

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Heritage Action for America Element tested: Advertising

Heritage Action sends their Annual Grassroots Survey to subscribers and donors on their file each year, and in 2019 they wanted to test whether it could help them acquire new subscribers and donors by promoting it on Facebook.

Because the survey works well with a carousel ad format, and because Facebook traditionally promotes the use of more advanced ad formats, we wanted to test the impact of a carousel ad which used in-app "swiping" between 5 screens, where there was a "cover image" + 4 "question-specific" images to promote the survey.



View the experiment »


11.3% lift How validating shared beliefs impacts name conversion on a pledge

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Billy Graham Evangelistic Association Element tested: Name Acquisition Copy

Billy Graham Evangelical Association has a significant amount of traffic going to a page called, "I am Not Ashamed." On this page, they ask Christians to sign the proclamation that they are not ashamed of the Gospel. They use Scripture to reinforce this statement, a message from the CEO and president, and a form for people to fill out to sign the pledge. In an effort to increase name conversion through this pledge, we hypothesized adding check boxes to the belief statement. Before signing the pledge, people would then have to physically check the boxes affirming that they believed in the proclamation.

View the experiment »


69.0% lift How the kind of language used on a donate button impacts traffic to the donation page

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: EWTN Element tested: Advertising

The National Catholic Register has a donate link on their homepage that brings people to their primary donation page. In an effort to increase the traffic to that page and ultimately increase donor conversion, we hypothesized using different language for the donation link. For the treatment version we used "Support the Register".

View the experiment »


-50.3% drop How a new serial ask decreased donor conversion rate

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Heritage Action for America Element tested: Donation Page Copy

In reviewing the Serial Ask results from a recent experiment where the social proof elements increased gift matching and revenue from serial ask donors from The Heritage Foundation, the team at Heritage Action wanted to test bringing the popup language which had previously increased donor conversion rates into the primary page so that visitors not on a desktop device could also see it.

View the experiment »


-16.3% drop How increasing perceived security on a primary donation page for mobile devices can impact donor conversion

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Billy Graham Evangelistic Association Element tested: Donation Page Form

One of the most common reasons web visitors don't complete transactions online is a perceived lack of security. Knowing this, Billy Graham Evangelical Association wondered if their primary donation pathway was losing potential donors because it didn’t visually represent how secure it was. They created a special security box around the credit card section of form and added a padlock into the shaded box to represent that the form was secure. This didn’t make the form more secure—it was already PCI compliant and had the highest levels of security. All these design tweaks did was increase perception of security with the end user. They launched an A/B test on all device types (desktop/mobile/tablet) to see if it increased donor conversion as they hypothesized.

View the experiment »


20.4% lift How increasing perceived security on a primary donation page for desktop devices can impact donor conversion

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Billy Graham Evangelistic Association Element tested: Donation Page Form

One of the most common reasons web visitors don't complete transactions online is a perceived lack of security. Knowing this, Billy Graham Evangelical Association wondered if their primary donation pathway was losing potential donors because it didn’t visually represent how secure it was. They created a special security box around the credit card section of form and added a padlock into the shaded box to represent that the form was secure. This didn’t make the form more secure—it was already PCI compliant and had the highest levels of security. All these design tweaks did was increase perception of security with the end user. They launched an A/B test to see if it increased donor conversion as they hypothesized.

View the experiment »


-15.4% drop How clarity in the subject line impacts open rate

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Care Net Element tested: Email Subject Line

On the introduction email for their new CareSource manager, Care Net wanted to determine if a more whimsical subject line would increase the engagement for the email. Since the email had a personal touch of a cookie recipe, it was decided to test an unusual subject line that included that information.

View the experiment »


9.6% lift How social proof improved the statement of belief’s email registration rate

Date Added: March 27, 2019 Research Partner: Alliance Defending Freedom Element tested: Name Acquisition Copy

After launching the statement of belief on the blog, ADF wanted to experiment with leveraging social proof as a way to improve pledge signature (or email capture / email registration) rates. The goal was to see if people would be more willing to add their name if they knew that they were joining with more than 10K other individuals.



View the experiment »